Dear YA Fiction,
I’m breaking up with you.

At least emotionally I am.
You ride on the wave of teen angst and drama.
You show happily ever afters.
You show hard things that work out.
You show dreams coming true.
My reality was much different.

I was raised by you. My idea of love, friendship, and college. My ideas of life were shaped by the things I read.
Looking back at my Teen years you did me very few favors. You hurt me more than anything else. The hours I spent crying over the broken heart of a character. The hours I spent crying because someone was abandoned in a book were real. I felt your pain. I felt your betrayals. I felt the joy when things worked out. I loved getting to feel those things but I’ve grown up now.
I know real life is much different. I know things don’t always work out. I know that the ending of the story isn’t always “happily ever after”.
I also know that when I look at the Teen fiction currently being published I am disappointed. You major in Girl characters, which is beautiful, but what am I supposed to hand the Teen boy coming into my library who doesn’t want to read their 15th book in a row with a female main character. You major in drama and relationships. What am I supposed to hand the boy who has read the Michael Vey series and the Pendragon series? They don’t want another book with a romantic relationship.
What about the girl who doesn’t believe in happily ever afters? Her life has shown her that those don’t exist. I can hand her “The Hate U Give” and “The Compound” but what then? What can I hand her when she’s tired of Rom Coms and Chick lit?
I love that we have more diverse books but Diversity shouldn’t mean that we stop writing anything for your already loyal and devoted readers. I look through the YA reviews online and I wonder where I’ll find books for these kids. Where will I find things to interest them? I can steer them towards Classics and Adult Literature but there is something beautiful about YA Lit and you are in a position to lose a lot of your readers.
I had a kid come in and want something funny. He was a Teen now. He loved the iFunny series by James Patterson but he was ready for something Teen related. What can I hand him? Where are the Teen books that make you laugh? Where are the Teen books that are lighthearted but not Rom Coms?
I love you YA Lit but you’ve lost me emotionally. My emotions are overdrawn. Don’t forget about me. Don’t forget about the kids who want something different. Don’t stop writing books for us because we are striving for Diversity. Diversity doesn’t mean we stop writing books that will appeal to this group. Diversity means we add, not subtract. I believe in you YA Fiction. You can do this.
-B












